Vista Nightmare: The “Oww!” Starts Now

Dear Microsoft Corporation,

You’ve really done it this time.

And I am leaving and never speaking to you again.

It’s not that I want to dislike you. I was loyal to you for so long.

I stuck with you through thick and thin. From DOS 5.0 through XP. Through decent functionality and through countless crashes.

But this new operating system is the last straw.

I’ve read through hundreds of online reviews and comments about Vista. I’ve asked IT guys and Microsoft Certified Professionals. I’ve read the PC magazine reviews. I’ve given it a spin on my friends’ laptops.

You’d think at least someone (other than your PR people) would find something to like about a piece of software that took an industry leader five years and a gazillion dollars to develop. But I’ve yet to hear anyone say “Wow!” about it.

There’s a few lukewarm praises like “it looks better than XP if you have a new graphics card.” But most people say it’s a just a naggy, inferior imitation of Mac OS X.

A Windows worshipping gamer acquaintance told me it took literally seven or eight hours of churning to install his Vista Home Premium (sic) upgrade. After staying up all night, he found none of his device drivers worked.

With the tales of the new DRM lockdown, the User Account Control nagging, the virtualization restrictions, and the priced-to-upsell $400 product – your credibility is about as good as OJ Simpson’s.

I just don’t trust what you say anymore.

It’s a shame because there were better times in our 15-year relationship. There was the golden era a few years back (around the dot com bubble) when Windows was the platform. There was an aura of innovation and lots of exciting software new coming out for Windows.

But those days are gone. And your days are numbered, Microsoft.

I had this epiphany when I tried out my friend’s Macintosh with OS X. I realized how much grief you’d put me through: the constant crashes whenever I tried to run more than three applications, the endless required reboots, and the vicious malware attacks that I wasted many precious hours wrangling with. And then having to pay extra for third party security and virus programs – because you couldn’t keep a handle on things.

But as a veteran power user – by grace or by service pack – I always managed to fix it.

Others aren’t so fortunate.

You’ve terrified folks like my poor dad. He is afraid to install new software for any reason. He mumbles things like “Computers – you just can’t trust them.” He’s been conditioned that if he tries to install a new program or download an update – even if he does it correctly – something is likely to go awry for no explicable reason. That’s why he sticks with IE 5 and Office 97, cause he sees upgrading as too risky to gamble with.

You made millions of poor secretaries and office workers cry just for trying to do normal things like printing and saving.

It didn’t have to be like this. Shame on you!

The secret is out, Microsoft. The reputation that you can’t be trusted to deliver reliable software is getting around fast.

Hasta la Vista!

This post was originally written by Brett Borders and it made the Digg home page.

Tags: , , ,

  • Marina

    Hello,


    May name is Marina and I’m student of the Marketing course of University of Sao Paulo, Brazil. My group is making an academic research about owners of communities and blogs like "ihate.com". Please, can you help us? You just need to answer the survey bellow:


    http://spreadsheets.google.com.....


    Thanks,
    Marina Arruda.

  • Mack2D2

    oh, and for the Aero haters... that's a setting you can turn off, you don't have to let it eat up your RAM.

  • Mack2D2

    Ya know, I've gotta come to Windows defense... I finally gave Vista a chance when I bought my newest computer... and while I definitely miss XP, I have had absolutely no problem with Vista. I don't experience all these "crashes" that people like you talk about, and I am even currently running 6 Firefox tabs and 5 total programs (Notepad, Adobe Illustrator, Photoshop, Firefox, and Zune music player) with no problem. I've even ran all these programs at the same time as playing Half-Life 2 using high settings, and experienced no crashes. Also, as far as virus problems go, I use a free anti-virus program called AVG (http://free.avg.com/), which is a little on the simple side for the free edition, but has proven quite dependable since I haven't had any problem at all with viruses.


    Personally, I think it's just "cool" to hate Microsoft nowadays. You're not "hip" if you don't talk trash about Bill Gates and pitch out an extra 1000 dollars (hyperbole) for a computer sporting equivalent power but w/ an apple slapped to the side of a nice bright white tower and the comfort of knowing that hackers could care less about attacking your OS right now (give them time, they attack Windows because it controls the majority of the market).


    <ul>
    <li>Just for the purpose of clarification, when I say "cool" and "hip", it probably portrays the image of an old man being loyal to his memories of Windows 3.1, that's not the case. I'm a 26 year old graphic designer who requires dependability out of his machine, as well as flexibility, the latter of which, I feel Mac's don't offer.</li>
    </ul>

  • Alexwebmaster

    Hello webmaster
    I would like to share with you a link to your site
    write me here preonrelt@mail.ru

  • Hugh

    Preston Promethius said:


    "I believe the majority of people who post pro-Vista comments are simply average computer users."


    Actually, some of the pro-Vista comments are from average users, but the majority are from seriously neuron-challenged Microsoft shills who are as hard to miss as a BSOD on live television. What a pathetic bunch of money-grubbing losers.

  • Mac

    Hello Iam Mac Thanks for really screwing up with Vista my sales really going up. Then when you started the Mojave Project hey look at mojave wow that "looks" good. You have just been punked It's Vista come on out ashton. You really make your customers feel like a dumbass. thanks for Double the sales

  • rockk

    nutin eva crashes on vista..
    wt u runnin it on? P1? Stupid config, stupid opinions.. Use vista on a decent pc..ull fall in luv wit it.. blame urself if u tryta run it on crap

  • rockk

    IT PRO up der talks sense

  • rockk

    idiots all of u mac lovers..
    Vista's da best.. ve used em all..
    neva a single crash.. aero's gr8, runs evytin, u just need a brain to recognize it n use it.. i dont use any antivirus too.. no viruses on vista..(i neva used 1 in xp, n no viruss den eidr(i manually remove em))
    The entire framewrk of vista is simply the best.. Ve used ubuntu, mac.. alla dem suck in frnta vista

  • Want to fight back? check out this link:
    http://combatwombat.7doves.com...

  • Anonymous

    hell i havent had any problems lol

  • I Hate Gates

    I hope MicroSoft gets hit by a meteor and all those fuckers die!

  • wanieda

    When you do a free spyware scan and find out you have spyware or adware on your computer, the first thing that comes to mind is how to get rid of the spyware on your computeradware spyware uninstall

  • plain-ordinary-asshole

    Hi all,


    I am just a plain ordinary asshole on a PC. I really like this blog - here. It is like someone has thrown a bucket of cold water on my head and said, "Hello - are U still there?"


    This is where PCing has brought me to. After 40 years of programming and tech work-arounds I am officially a PC Geezer who needs new glasses now.


    The reason why I refer to myself as a "plainordinaryasshole" is because I don't understand why I am too stoopid not to upgrade to Ubuntu. I feel so sorry for Microsoft. I think that those many users who still use MS products are purely and simply addicted to the punishment it delivers with each new migration and each new update and each new patch. I would of thought it would be better by now.


    I dunno .. are we all addicted to migrains or sumthing?


    regards, plain -o-a

  • I have had the freedom of working on Mac OS X at an office years ago and discovered I would only reboot once a year.


    Even with Office XP I reboot about once a week. Vistsa works best on a machine with a performance rating of 5.0 or better (Microsoft's grading scale). My new XPS Dell 420 is running a 5.4 on the scale and runs Vista well.


    On a bad note, you can't find many discounted software titles yet that work on Vista.

  • hemppy

    I upgraded from windowsXp 2nd edition to Vista home premium.
    I was fighting with my computer to get a clean install when it dawned on me that Vista is a different windows from WinXp so of course i had to upgrade my software the problem is with Roxio i upgraded to Roxio MYDVD9 and Microsoft WORKS9 and i got a clean install and installed my drivers from Dell websight. And something else helped i setup another user administrator this is where i install when i am downloading while the other connection is for play and looking up what i want to look up. So if you have an error correct it on your administrator con and it when you are downloading it will make a restore date and i set it to restore once a week and my pc automaticly maintains my pc. Good advice my friends try it so don't be afraid of Vista another thing find out if u have a Vista32 or 64 don't mix download a 64 if u have a vista32 error city U.S.A wish i could share more but out of room lol good luck and keep computing.

  • Wow was I surprised at all the Microsoft bashers... I do agree Vista has some faults, but hey could we write an operating system...no way.


    I am still using XP on my 320 with dual core with 2 Gig Ram mirrored machine. Guess I was a little hesitant to go with Vista when I did my last upgrade. But I have worked on MACs and if MAXC users were truthful they would tell you how many PhotoShop and Illustrator and In Design files they lost due to an OS crash from the Apple Bomb. I know that is why I run a PC for all my Graphics apps. I do web development, design, my own hosting and SEO and I can offer a tip. Feel sorry for those who have Vista if they have problems and be glad it is not you. Be nice and send them a link to this blog and maybe some of the great tips listed above will help someone in need.
    Loved the posts they made me have my smile for the day!

  • BillC

    I'm a long time Windows user (3.0) and DOS (god maybe 2. something) before that. I've installed networks from IBM's PCNET to WFWG, LanManger, Novell, W2k, W2K3 and most recently Linux with a Novell interface and I've never lost any significant data until tonight with VISTA. The more I use it, the more I dislike it. I copied and pasted a folder (PUBLIC) from C: to D: drive. It was apparently there - I viewed the files; they were there and then I couldn't access the drive, the permissions were screwed up and now it(the data)- gone .... I've struggled with this laptop for 2 months. I believe I'm done.

  • Anonymous

    Think about doughnuts, for a change...

  • Anonymous

    Geeks- and non-geeks, you all miss the point. Technology is nothing in itself. And limitation constitue our life.
    I might sound like a fascist, but a person deserves freedom.


    Free software rules!

  • Sier9iej

    "a sad life of jonathan harchick"


    this idiot is everywhere, he just HATE APPLE without any reason.


    His sick in mind!


    LIAR, coward, idiot, primitve like hell, fat, no life, low-life form.


    LMAO!

  • roy

    Biggest piece of crap to come down the line

  • Kris

    I think Vista was a great idea. I've run Windows ever since 3.1. Microsoft has done me the service of forcing me to Linux, because Vista will never be allowed to enter my house.


    I've got a new quad processor PC coming in next week with NO OPERATING SYSTEM, and then I'll figure out how to install a Debian kernal that supports multiple processors.


    Thank you Microsoft, for making our relationship so miserable that I finally decided to leave you.

  • mark godfrey

    oh sweet Lord but it's true.


    MS you are absolutely killing me.


    After years and years of defending you, I get this.

  • Seannypoos

    Vista - let's sum it up really quickly what kind of STUPID IDIOTIC company "develops" an OS that can no longer read the Help files of Office programs from a few years ago? What company develops an OS and then sstrips things out of it uunless you pay more? I won't bother to go into SIX hours of repeated attempts to get a simple Lexmark printer to run (YES it was with the correct driver), then there's the internet - three attempts - sees my router ok but will it run? No. Three days later - it starts to work! no reason just felt like it no doubt. Compare this with a Nintendo Wii - select Internet, Find Router, What's the encryption key please? Thank you- here's your internet service ready to run sir. TWO MINUTES FLAT!
    And as for that infernal "windows is looking for a solution" when you've asked it to kill a program for the umpteenth time. I rest my case. The only good thing to come of this is the Windows death knell sounding across the globe. Thank you for that at least Microsoft, oh and could you switch the light off when you leave? No don't bother I'll do it, I doubt if you could even do that without asking permission and confirmation at least three times!

  • steve

    The cabal of brainiacs who developed and sold this vista lemon should be reassigned to Microsofts version of Siberia. They can join the "new coke", Yugo, and McRib masterminds in their castle of shame.

  • steve

    Microsoft needs to open up it's fat nerdy velcro wallet and fix this vista fiasco before class actions do it for them.

  • steve

    vista is like an unreliable, unpredictable and faulty escalator as compared to a short set of stairs

  • JeffH from OH

    Vista is garbage. Windows Explorer and Internet Explorer crash all the time. Printers don't work properly even with correct printer drivers. Palm pilot software won't load. Microsoft Office locks up regularly. This is all on a new Vista desktop system I bought about 4 months ago. Most of my software disks--including Microsoft products--won't even install in Vista. I buying a Mac for my daughter this Christmas, and probably getting myself one.

  • MACS ARE A HUGE SCAM

    MAC = UNEDUCATED YUPPIE CONSUMERS WHO BELIEVE DUMBED DOWN MARKETING


    KEEP BUYING THOSE IPHONES, YOU CAN EVEN REPLACE THE BATTERY(JUST LIKE THE IPUD), AND IF YOU PUT ANY UNAUTHORIZED SOFTWARE ON YOUR IPHONE, APPLE WILL BRICK IT WITH THEIR SOFTWARE UPDATES. OH AND I BELIEVE THEY ARE BEING SUED FOR USING SOME TYPE OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS.


    AND YOU COMPLAIN MS IS TOO CONTROLLING. IT IS EXACTLY THE OPPOSITE.


    BUY A MAC AND THEY TELL YOU WHAT HARDWARE AND SOFTWARE YOU CAN RUN, AND WHEN IT DOES BREAK(AND IT WILL) THEY BANG YOU OUT BIG TIME TO FIX IT. $100-$200 TO REPLACE A BATTERY? COME ON. I HAVE A HTC PC PHONE(8125 WIZARD) FROM 2 YEARS AGO AND IT STILL CRUSHES THE IPHONE. THE NEW HTC KAISER IS CHEAPER, UNRESTRICTED, AND YOU CAN REPLACE YOUR BATTERY ALL BY YOURSELF.


    I GUESS THATS WHY TERMS LIKE MORON, IDIOT, AND IMBECILE ARE ACTUALLY TECHNICAL TERMS. IF YOU ARE PRO MAC, YOU PROBABLY FALL INTO THE BOTTOM 25%. DON'T BE MAD AT ME, TRY EDUCATING YOURSELF AND RISE ABOVE THE MAC MINDEDNESS(LOW IQ RANGES).

  • IT PRO FROM DAY 1

    Final cut pro is a joke.
    Try Vegas Video or Premiere, they are MUCH better.


    And for supercomputing such as the human genome project, linux would crush Windows or MAC OS any day of the week.


    Before you open your mouth, actually know what you are talking about.


    MAC MORONS.


    Oh and by the way I started prior to Commodore, IBM AT/XT, and the TI home computer(we stored our programs on audio cassette tapes).
    I have also supported many Macs for large customers (graphic design houses) and they absolutely are horrible to work on. Supposedly they never break. What a lie. Apple support is a waste of time. I know more about Macs then they do and their solution is usually "Just reinstall the OS, or you need a new motherboard(about $850 usually). When I would show these customers that a PC could do the same job as a Mac, only faster with way more hardware and software to choose from, they were always shocked. And after deploying some PC's the rest of the Macs fell quite quickly. There used to be only one reason to have a Mac, and that was commercial print houses only due to the way Quark handled fonts on the Mac. That day has come and gone.
    BYE BYE MAC!!!

  • IT PRO FROM DAY 1

    Oh by the way for all you Apple idiots:


    APPLE=FISHER PRICE


    A shiny toy for children who are technologically inept.


    (What hardware does apple run now? Oh thats right they finally wised up and went with Intel. LOL)

  • IT PRO FROM DAY 1

    Vista runs great. Get over it. 64 bit cpu with 64 bit os. Stay away from nvidia crap, they have dragged their asses on software support and their mobo chipsets are notorious for compatability problems. XP had way more issues all they way until SP1a was released. Before SP1a it was GARBAGE. How quickly we forget. I have seen and installed EVERY release of windows and Vista has the fewest problems out of the box from day 1 period. ***BONUS-VISTA WILL SAVE YOUR ASS ONE DAY. DELETED OR MODIFIED FILES CAN BE RETRIEVED BY SIMPLY GOING TO PROPERTIES OF THE FOLDER THAT CONTAINED THE FILE, CLICK THE PREVIOUS VERSIONS TAB AND VISTA WILL SAVE YOUR DAY. I HAVE SEEN IT SEVERAL TIMES ALREADY AND THE USER IS ALWAYS EXTREMELY GRATEFUL.


    For all you "Power Users"(LOL) learn about hardware, software, technology, and integration before you bash a good product. Since you are a "Power User", you probably buy Dell(LOL) or build inferior machines with crappy MOBO's/CPU'S and then wonder why your crappy hardware doesnt run a new os properly. New technology usually requires new hardware.(Apple is far worse with hardware than MS ever was or will be). I build plenty of machines and they all run Vista like a champ, even an old IBM P3 Intellistation, but then again it has an intel chipset.


    Damn ID-10-T errors.

  • A poetic way of expressing disgust. What should Microsoft learn that they don't know yet?

  • Anonymous

    It amazes me that a few people still carry stone age ideas about Macs in their heads, saying things like Macs are just "pretty" and can't do "serious" stuff. Do these people have ANY IDEA how many well known TV shows and big name hollywood movies are produced on a Macs running Final Cut Studio? or that vast amounts genes for the Human Genome Project were sequenced on Macs.
    Todays Intel based Macs can run Mac OSX, Windows, Ubuntu and more.
    Microsoft Office?, Open Office? Take your pick!


    I could go on, but looking at Apple's rapidly rising Mac sales figures, it looks like most people are smart enough to figure out who is winning here...

  • Robin

    Mac sucks, whoever told you it's better for music, that is your enemy. If you don't have problems with your Win config, don't even think about switching to Mac. It's just another computer with the marketing hype around it. And except for the Macbook, it's fairly expensive. but again, the Macbook is not capable of any serious project. I always get these system overflow messages in Logic 7.2.. so I just wanted to highlight that even though Vista may have some problems, the whole environment is much better there under Windows for creative work.

  • Frustrated

    My frustration actually didn't start with Vista.. it started with Windows Mobile 2002 in my Jornada 928. The HP made a great piece of hardware but for some inconceivable for me reason had to put in a buggy & raw system. The satisfaction from using it is the same as from using Vista - only present with a prefix dis-.

  • small follow-up about dashes

    Hi Brett, after looking at my submitted post, I noticed your site replaced my uses of double-dashes (the poor-man's m-dash), with single dashes, or possibly n-dashes (hard to tell without some effort). Which of course completely changes the meaning. A double dash (or m-dash) is like a parenthetical aside; an independent though (usually supplementary), inline with the main though. A single dash or n-dash is completely different, and swapping one for the other can (and does and did) completely change the meaning, such as with many of the passages I wrote just previously. (In most cases it just made whole sentences incomprehensible!)

  • Ex-Microsoft employee tries Ma

    I was so disgusted with Vista, I quit Microsoft over it. Kid you not. Four months ago.


    After using it for about three months at work on a high-powered notebook and desktop, and losing countless hours of work and sleep and files over it, I had absolutely had enough!


    I've been a Microsoft OS power user since MS-DOS 3.3 (long before I joined Microsoft), and upgraded at every step. I've grappled with Windows as a programmer, power use, photographer, recording musician, manager, video hobyist, small business owner, IT manager, you name it.


    I've installed Windows of various flavors well over a hundred times or more. I've been the Unofficial-Official (and unwilling) tech support guru for friends and family all the way--and (regrettably) introduced most of them to Windows in the first place.


    I was furious when Windows 98 came out. It was Windows 95, with most of the more glaring bugs fixed. And they had the gall to CHARGE me for it. But I already PAID for Windows 98's beta test (called "Windows 95"). But, I sucked it up. (I did skip Windows ME. Not gonna sucker me twice, or three times, or whatever the count was up to.) But I remained a loyal Microsoft customer and eventually went to work for them.


    Vista changed all that. (Office 2007 really pushed me over the edge.) Now I have a new outlook. No more Microsoft. I don't dislike them as a company or as an employer. They tried very hard. And the people are talented and individually try very hard and want to do the right thing. (It's really the lawyers and marketers that screw everything up...not to mention fear of shareholders [ironically the uninformed day traders and fund managers who could care less about the company or products and are just out there gambling and increasing market volatility].)


    Nevertheless, as a result of these infuriating new products (and indeed the history), Microsoft has gotta go from my life.


    First, I thought that Mac OS X was the answer, so I bought a MacBook. It took me a while to get used to the "maximize button that doesn't", and the "closing a one-window app's one window still leaves the app quietly running" issue, and the mixed-up hotkeys (which I've learned to prefer).


    But I'm used to these and other issues now, and although the Mac and Finder has just as many functional quirks and little annoyances as Windows and Explorer, overall the Mac is clean, pretty, and everything works. (I also fixed the inconsistent GUI theme with "Uno". A bit annoying that I had to do that--if I can't skin the UI out of the box, at least make it consistent between built-in applications.)


    One observation (not really a complaint because it's easy to mitigate): If ever an OS was presented as a "toy" (as XP was often accused of), Mac OS X is it. While running on industrial strength UNIX, the bundled GUI applications were created for rank noobs. While simple and easy to use, they tend to have an apalling lack of configurability. But no biggy--there's plenty of third-party software out there.


    The real problem with the Mac--fatal problem in fact--is the true cost of choosing it: absolute vendor lock-in. What's worse, it's not just a "one-decision" lock-in (or two decision--OS AND hardware). The more you use a Mac and come to depend and rely on it as more and more of your data and habits become locked into it, the more likely ALL of your future hardware and OS decisions will be locked into the Mac. No thanks! Been there, have the scars. In truth, in that way it's twice as bad as Windows.


    So better late than never, I decided--without ever having even tried it--to switch ALL of my machines (including the MacBook) to Linux. Actually in hindsight, I would have chosen OpenBSD, as it is much more "free as in speech" than the GPL model of most Linux distros. Oh well.


    I went with Ubuntu, sight unseen. Installation was easy (I know it can be a nightmare to install--but paying $300 for a nightmare vs. a free nightmare are very different things.)


    Admittedly, on the MacBook I am still using Ubuntu full-time in a VMware Fusion virtual machine, on a completely stripped down and crippled OS X login. With the snapshot feature, it is very forgiving. And fast! For now, I have no reason to invest the time in a real install, because I can't tell that it isn't.


    Since I am not investing any more time or data or habits into Mac OS X, it doesn't matter that I'm still "technically" still using it under the hood. I think of it now as a glorified boot loader (well a boot-loader that still takes up 400mb of RAM). For now, the damage is done--I purchased a Mac, the money is gone. Wiping the disk would not accomplish any more liberation than I've already achieved--using Linux every moment of my computing existence.


    I'm the kind of person who must know absolutely everything about a technology that I adopt. I keep forgetting that. (Even after I just went through the same thing with my shiny new Mac OS X.) Thus, about ten days of mostly all-nighters and alienating my family were thrust upon me, as I learned Linux inside and out. It was a painful transition. It is so different than Windows. (In fact for obvious reasons, it's closer to Mac OS X at the guts level.) But at the end, I felt reborn. (Or maybe it was the lack of food, water, and sleep.)


    No only do I feel reborn, I feel up-born. I have a much higher awareness of the world of operating systems now. I learned about UNIX and all of it's derivatives. To my amazement, I learned that virtually every OS in use in the world today--except for Windows--was derived from UNIX (or the ancestors to what is not UNIX). IBM AIX, Sun Solaris, Linux, Mac's Darwin, you name it. Now that I have a reasonable handle on Linux (a process that started with Mac OS X), I know ALL operating systems. Well, most anyway.


    I am now a Linux evangelist. With GNOME at least, it is an amazing system, and amazingly USABLE system, and just an amazing idea. And I'm still trying to wrap my head around the fact that it is open-source. How did this amazing gem come to be? (Not to mention GNOME, package managers like Synaptic, and the thousands of other free and open applications and utilities!) I keep trying to imagine how the projects are organized, with people working in their free time with no pay, no competition for raises and bigger offices. I can't picture it. My Microsoft brain is in danger of exploding.


    Either way, it's amazing, and I have resolved to contribute back in some way. Tester, possibly even developer and host of some new open-source project (after I learn Python--no way I'm going to re-learn C!).


    Whether or not Mac OS X is better than Linux (say, Ubuntu) is not the point. (And by the way--Linux, at least with GNOME--trounces Mac OS X. This opinion is from a user with zero preconceived biases about either [actually not quite true--I had the vague notion that the Mac would be better than Linux] and with equal--and significant--time on both.)


    The point is--even if Mac (or Windows) were better than Linux--that Linux is F-R-E-E. Free as in "Freedom". Freedom from DRM intruding on your life and encumbering your work even after you paid for it. Freedom from paying for software which the vendor spends a significant portion of working in ever more restrictive DRM schemes making it harder for you to use. Freedom from vendor lock-in. Freedom from the dictates of idiots in a Marketing department touting focus group numbers. Freedom from share-price slavery. Freedom from a significant portion of the cost of software being spent on advertising and marketing. Freedom from magazine editors being "bought off" for good reviews. (It happens--maybe not in so blatant of terms--but any reviewer for a publication that accepts ad money from the companies with said products being reviewed, is ultimately under some pressure, which all ads up as a whole to a significant skewing of general opinion. Trust me, there are whole organizations devoted to insuring favorable reviews, that have nothing whatsoever to do with making the product better.) Freedom from marketing budgets influencing more users than the quality of the product. Freedom from vendors being (or feeling) forced to introduce new features, before fixing old broken ones.


    And here's something I've never heard anyone else mention. There's one more freedom that Linux offers: FREEDOM FROM VICTIMIZATION. The state of being a victim (except in cases involving felony offenses) is often more about a feeling. You FEEL like a victim, and that upsets you. When something randomly bad happens to you, you can choose to feel like a victim, or you can choose to recognize your own bad choices (if applicable), and/or you can choose to shrug it off as best you can and move on, as best you can. When bad things happen and your OS is to blame, if it's Windows or Mac, you feel like a victim. You paid for this cr*p, and now it has turned on you, and your data is gone. Linux releases you from that victim mindset. Hey--it's FREE. So what if it has a few hitches? (If it did, that is. So far, I haven't found any.) You figure out how to work through it, and move on. By doing so, you consciously choose to take responsibility for your fate, you choose to act, and you choose to remain grateful for the free gifts you have.


    Long Live Freedom! I'm never going back.

  • Anonymous

    I think the appropriate word to describe Vista is "eye-candy". It looks like candy, it has everything to make it look a bit better - but nothing more.
    Rounded, shiny, colorful - that's what it is like! The Aurora wallpaper reminds me on sugar with some food colouring. Most of these things are possible to get on XP. XP is the best OS by Microsoft.
    P.S. GET A MAC ANYWAY!!!

  • Well, I really can agree with you. I have used Windows since version 1 all the way to XP. For a couple of years ago I bought a Powerbook, just to have a portable computer as well. I instantly liked OS X and today I really prefer using my Powerbook.


    A couple of month ago I tested Vista. I never noticed any "Wow"... All I noticed that all the features I cared about already existed - in my two year old install of OS X. Smart folders, a fast way to search files and so on. Nothing new really. Besides the new interface and the UAC that annoyed the h*ll out of me.


    http://www.gate303.net/2007/06...

  • Nick

    If you're planning on upgrade from XP to Vista on your old system. My advice is to DON'T DO IT. I did that on my brother's PC and it was running so slow. I ended up building a new system using higher processor,Video card and lots and lots of RAM. See, Microsoft will tell you that it will run but they didn't tell you that it will run at a snail speed. If you really want Vista that bad buy a new system that comes with it and go for the best system that you can pick otherwise it's just not worth it. And now there's another problem with my machine. That damn freaking drive will not stop churning. I turned off the indexing. Disable anything related to indexing and it still churn not as much but it still does. When it does that it slows my system down dramatically. My recommendation, if you're happy with XP then don't switch it. Vista is not that much different than XP except it looks nicer that's all.

  • elias

    send me this

  • Vista is crap. It is the most annoying OS I have ever used since Amiga days. Have only been able to install it successfully on one system from out of 5 systems. I also work with Gentoo and OSX. OSX just destroys Vista from every single perspective. Gentoo is another story but I feel more comfortable and safe in Gentoo than I do in Vista.

  • Cameron

    True that...Microsoft has had it. The article, funny, yet very true. I myself am now switching to Mac...Thanx everyone

  • Well I don't have to say a thing. Just google for what information it is sending home! May be a idea for next article.
    http://geemodo.blogspot.com/20...

  • The truth is that Windows Vista has quite a few "wow" features, but like all Microsoft operating systems it will take some time for the public to warm up to it. Of course, there is always the loud minority with an axe to grind that will continually taunt any Microsoft software release.

  • Loughlin

    I've been using Vista for 3 weeks now - I'm a web developer who has never bought into all this shite about mac vs pc, win vs linux. Vista is a great improvement on XP, UAC can be disabled, the interface is really, really nice and with the right memory specs the OS runs very smoothly. I think Microsoft have hit the nail on the head with this one.


    I think it's great.

  • Oh no! My Vista nightmare! I got it preinstalled on my laptop and... the setup worked! :O


    I went to Toshiba's website to upgrade my graphics card's drivers and... surprise, it worked!


    I decided to install my copy of Office 2007 and... it worked!


    I went to play GTA:San Andreas and guess what? IT WORKED!


    I've not encountered one single problem in Vista that wasn't easy to resolve. I've not got a BSOD on it in the 4 months I've had this laptop. Where are all these supposed problems?


    (okay, installing the graphics card's drivers may have frozen my laptop, and sometimes aero turns off when I run a RAM and CPU hungry application but forgets to turn it back on again, but that's about it)

  • Mike

    I just bought a new laptop from Dell, the website didn’t allow me to customise the OS so I phoned Dell and requested XP installed as standard unfortunately they said they can only supply Vista on the model I chose. I opted for a 9 cell battery having read reviews that it may last up to 7 hours, apparently these review were based on an XP operating system because my 9 cell battery only lasts 3 to 4 hour running vista and I wasn’t doing anything processor intensive with it either.


    I am a graphic designer and 3d animator, so the real question for me is will Lightwave and Photoshop work under vista? And if so will it render 3d scenes slower than XP? Assuming my software will install and run under vista I’m going render out a scene using lightwave, then format the drive, install XP and render the same scene again. If the scene renders significantly faster under XP then I wont be using vista.


    Vista seems to work ok if you only need to surf the net and type up your home work, but those users who use the cpu to it’s full potential are probably better off using XP. However as I have found the only way to know if Vista is for you is to simply test it out, find out if vista will do what you need it to do and them compare that to XP and then make an informed decision as to which OS works best for your own needs.

  • When I read a post as to the high price of Macs, I'm once again reminded that most PC users have low end machines. Do not compare apples to oranges, no half-pun intended. I'm pricing high end machines for my company, both PCs and Macs, and at the high end, they are equal, if not the PC a thousand or two (dollars) more. If you are running a sub $10K machine, you are amongst the 99% of computer users who know nothing of, nor care to know, the high end, and happily exist in blissful ignorance! (It IS bliss if you can settle!) Unfortunately, you pay for what you expect!


    As to comparing OS flavors, and rant about this or that OS breaking rules and such... These attempts at computer-human ergonomics are all just guesses, programmed by giant committee. Committee-think lowers the I.Q. of a room usually by 12 points a person, which puts, especially Microsoft, the giant company that it is, into drooling idiot territory. Apple has fewer involved, but they have their own issues. Just 20 people working on an OS would need John Milton as its leader to maintain a positive I.Q., but he's long dead, so there you are. Nobody has it right by miles... or light years. Get over it! Or better, program us something better! Put the world to rights.


    Marketing wise, I can see the angst of the Windows world. Apple is slicker, by far, because they understood that it's "YOUR computer," not "a PC." HP is beginning to understand that dynamic, but again, when you get to the high end, it's all priced the same.

  • If you liked this post. You'd like this similiar one too.
    vistasucks.wordpress.com/2007/...

  • roxpace

    It's childish to say that Microsoft Windows Vista is not ready for the market.


    Learn what Microsoft suggests as hardware requirements and it will work just very fine, in fact much better than Windows XP which can be a slow hog if you are running two memory intensive softwares at the same time, with Vista it goes fast with same hardware platform.


    And why nagging about UAC ? Sure it can annoy, but if you are one of those who prefers to not see those popup warning windows when you are near to damage any secure related settings, then disable UAC and get no more naggings.


    Why comparing Mac OS X with Vista ? Pretty dumb comparing, two totally different OS with GUI, they are not near similar in the GUI handling. Sure both tries to look fancy and hype, but thats it. Try to do anything advanced under Mac OS X and you need to learn UNIX, in that fact Vista is much easier.


    Now to explain more, I am NOT a Windows Vista fanatic, my main OS is actually FreeBSD, so far away I can come from Windows, but Windows Vista was a positive experience on my machines, and that is honest words and nothing else.

  • Count me in as another unhappy Vista user

  • Chris

    "is this an idiotic post to try and be cool?"


    Yes, that is what your post was! Thanks for telling us before hand!

  • victor

    Got new laptop with vista for college. It took 7 minutes to boot the very first time. I then installed Ubuntu. It uses new Santa Rosa chipset, so it took me and one other about a week to get everything working. But now IT WORKS and will stay working forever. I use XP on 4 other computers and it really is true that you have to re-install it every 6 months to maintain reasonable speeds.


    I will never use vista thankgod.

  • Ralph

    I have a friend who regularly lambasts me about my Mac use. This same friend has been an XP user for several years. He has had issues with adware, viruses, spyware, and trojans. Eventually he bought a new computer which came with Vista. He gave his old machine to his son who now tries also to lambast me about using a Mac. He has had to send his Vista machine in for repair twice already, but still swears blind to me that it is a superior machine to his XP machine. In the meanwhile, I have run OSX (10.0, 10.1, 10.3, 10.4) for six years and have only suffered one OS crash in that period. During the same time, I have had to use Win2000 at work and have had to return three computers for repair because they not only suffered the BSoD but eventually failed to work completely. Is this because I am an OSX user and hence tried to use Windows as an OSX machine and caused my own difficulties? Let's consider - I moved the taskbar to the top of the screen because that was where I was used to seeing it.... And that was it. That was the only thing I inflicted on my Windows machine. But it still failed. And my friend's Vista machine is failing despite the fact he is attempting (through account separation and Parental Controls) to limit the damage that might be inflicted by non-savvy users. At the end of this, he still tells me that his system is superior to mine - that it is cheaper, more reliable, has a wider array of compatible software, and represents better value for money. I bought my system, including the freely installed software (Yes, I'll ignore the Office Mac Test Drive) for less than the total cost of his lower configured Vista machine with it's craplets, system failures, service costs ($50 per visit to the service centre), and required software (Office). I have heard of Microsoft addiction being compared to the Stockholm Syndrome. What does the above sound like to you?

  • derry

    no. 24


    err... amsn works fine with msn and so does the webcam,


    err... kopete works fine with msn and so does the webcam,

  • Gordy

    Like many I used to be a DEVOTED Microsoft user- switched to a MacBook laptop, then upgreaded to a full tower system-- I am now a DEVOTED Apple user-- only so many times you can be jilted by the same company before you move on.

  • Tim

    My partner is a developer at MS and he and all of his coworkers insantly put it on their home computers when it first cae out . . .then a couple weeks later they all went back to XP because Vista did not work and was too slow.
    My own expereince is that it is slow, I get a zillion stupid error messages that make no sense, a lot of my programs do not work . . .
    For example, I use a #d program called Poser and Vista was incompatable with it. I had to turn a bunch of things off in Poser to git it to work - this took a couple weeks to sort out.
    I have not gone back to XP because I fear the transition . . . I am hoping that things get upgraded so it will work in the future. . . I am waiting for service releases to fix my problems.
    Don't have Vista yet - avoid it - at least for a year until they get their act togeher.
    Don't be a test for MS. They should hire their own testers!
    (I know a bunch they laid off.)

  • ERM

    I bought a laptop for my father-in-law with Windows Vista and he hated it. So I built him a desktop with XP and he's thanked me a bunch of times. I think XP was their Zenith.


    He also really liked Ubuntu, but this website he frequents uses WMV....who does that anymore?

  • Preston Promethius

    I believe the majority of people who post pro-Vista comments are simply average computer users. They don't game, they don't do graphics and 3D design, they don't program and do CPU intensive operations; they simply surf the net and check email. For all of us who "really" use computers for what they were supposedly meant for, Vista is the Godfather of Suck. I agree, most users will "oooh" and "ahh" at Aero, and try to impress their friends that they are "hip and trendy" by purchasing Vista PC's, and they will succeed at winning over more computer casuals to Vista, increasing Microsoft's profit and stocks. Eye candy is nice, but functionality and productivity are way more important. I hope this post might sway another potential sucker from the grips of the Microsoft ankle weight, Vista.

  • r3nny

    Someone above said:
    "Me, I wwas running Windows NT, coding websites, running SQL and 10 other apps with no problems. That was circa 1995."


    Guess what? You still are. Vista is just another revision of NT. It's XP with some revision/extension of the kernel and an updated windowing environment.


    DX10 isn't on XP for the simple reason that MS wants to force you to buy Vista. They could easily backport it with a service pack to handle any changes to other OS layers.

  • Dannie

    I had thousands problems in windows as well, since I bought a MacBook Pro. After one year experience on Mac, one thing I have to say:


    xp and vista are for people who deserve pain.


    Get the easy life. Get a Mac!

  • KnotTubeRight

    I really like Vista now that I have it tweaked to near perfection. Be sure to disable UAC User Access Control and DEP Data Execution Prevention. Then you can enjoy Vista like it should be. But then again , if you do all that you might as well be using XP. Really , if you disable all the security features, all you have left is XP with eye candy.

  • Jeff Olsen

    "Wow! This sucks!!!" is exactly what I said a week after upgrading to Vista. It made my year-old PC feel like an old 486. Then there's the drivers that don't work, programs that don't run, and the bad joke known as UAC. I have never been so disappointed in an OS upgrade in my life.


    And by the way, Aero is downright ugly and distracting once you get over the "shiny object" factor. Not that I ever really liked the childish look of XP, but I had really hoped MS would get it right this time. They didn't. I constantly felt like my eyes were out of focus with the odd mix of blur, transparency, and gloss. And just because you have 16,777,215 colors to play with doesn't mean you have to use them all at the same time!


    Anyway, I've switched back to XP for the time being. What a nightmare that was! I guess if you buy the Vista upgrade they deactivate your old XP product key. I had to call and convince some guy who barely speaks English that I'm not a criminal trying to rip-off the oh-so-poor Microsoft. He finally read me this huge number that I had to type into XP to get it activated again.


    The bottom line is FU Microsoft! I'm going to be in the vicinity of an Apple store on Tuesday and will very likely pick up a new MacBook Pro. I've had a friend who's been trying to get me to switch for a couple of years and I've blown him off in hopes that Vista would be great. All I can say now is, "Wow! I should've bought a Mac."

  • david

    i disagree entirely. I used to be an avid Linux user, having switched over from XP about five years ago. When I purchased my new laptop which came standard with Vista, I was utterly blown away. Everything works instantly, the computer looks amazing, and... everything good about a computer comes true. I set up Linux on the computer as a dualboot, but I still find myself booting into Vista way more often.


    As far as OSX goes, I'm forced to use that at work... and it doesn't even come close to counting as an operating system in my mind. is so flawed it's ridiculous.

  • Thomas Mazzone

    I'm not going to read all your messages, however everyone had his own and more or less convincing experiences with Windows XP, Mac OS X, or with another less popular OS.
    I'm not saying OS X is perfect nor trying to convince you, but c'mon, I must confess, I really pity Windows users, and that I find Linux longtime pioneers really courageous.
    Regards

  • I installed Vista Home Prem on a new system and it's okay. It's prettier than XP and has little more flexibility. It crashes some times. Actually, I think MS word is worse. My advice is if you have XP stay with XP. If you buy a new system and flexibility and speed are essential then install XP. If you're like me and like to putz around with new stuff then Vista won't kill ya.


    Kmuzu

  • Lots of longtime diehard Windows users are switching to Mac. There is a learning curve for OS X, but once you're over that you will be looking at a much more positive user experience.

  • chris

    I don't get what the big deal about Ubuntu is. I am currently running it on my laptop, personally out of all the linux distros I still prefer Red Hat or Fedora.


    I really doubt that Ubuntu will ever become a mainstream OS. I've had a lot more problems with Ubuntu than I ever had installing Vista.

  • dd

    @ the ol fisherman


    This guy is another example of someone spewing FUD, rather than looking objectively. Up until 6 months ago, I was the only Mac user among my friends. We shared many files with each other. Sure, some of our applications were different and we needed the version for our platform, but that was it. We could all listen to the same music files, avi files, mpg files, etc. Macs use all the same standards. It's Windows that uses proprietary formats nowadays.


    Ol Fisherman also mentioned how Mac users make life miserable with "hard to understand and harder to follow directions for programs..." Interesting. What's more difficult?


    Here's the comparison.
    For Windows, installation for 99.9% of applications means running an installer. For Mac, I'd say 90% of "installation" is dragging a file to your applications folder. And just to clarify, you can drag your application to any place you'd like to put it. It just makes sense to keep your applications in one folder.


    2) In Windows, to remove those same installations, you need to open the Control Panel,select Add/Remove programs, run the uninstall, and possibly reboot. In Mac, to remove those same "installations," drag said folder(s) to trash and empty.


    Sorry, Ol Fisherman. I believe you to be a giant liar and/or simply ignorant.

  • the ol fisherman

    Sorry-old eyes and numb fingers hit the return instead of the shift. Anyhoo, I was lookin at Macs and was not only very put off by their price, but also by the fact that I don't want to buy something that doesn't have the global application that windows has. EVERYONE has windows and in my circles, about the only ones using those goofy macs are the computer nerds who make our lives miserable by writing all these hard to understand and harder to follow directions for programs that I will never use and could care less about. Nope - Windows will have a loyal following for many many years to come because it's the industry standard, whether you want to believe it or not, and all the whining from tech geeks in the world won't change that. If you guys really wanted to do something useful instead of complaining, hows about stopping all the stupid spyware bundled with all these fancy "advanced" programs? I'm goin fishin.

  • dd

    So much back-and-forth nonsense here...
    I have multiple Windows-using friends; some of them even claim to actually like Windows. That's fine. I won't argue with people's preferences. However, none of them will switch to Vista. Vista is a giant mess and its advantage over XP is no different than Windows ME's advantage was over Windows 98. That's right. There's none.


    I've also seen some statements about Mac out here that are 10000% false. Again, I don't mind people's preferences and it is ok to not like the Mac platform, but at least state the facts.
    1) Trial software - There is ONE piece of trial software that has come with my last few Macs. Know what it is? Microsoft Office Test Drive. You know how to delete it? That's right - throw it in the trash. NO need to "uninstall" anything.
    2) Macs ask for username and password just like Vista - NOT true. The only installations that ask for that are ones that write to system libraries. Otherwise, 90% of "installations" are simply dragging applications to your application folder. Nothing gets written to the system and, consequently, nothing sneaks in and starts running in the background.
    3) Malware for Macs - Ok, in labs, these do exist. In the wild, they do not. Why not? Because, there has been no easy way to get an infected Mac to continue to infect other Macs. YES, you can get Microsoft Office on Macs to become the carrier to infect other Macs/PCs with Microsoft stuff, but then, that's more of an MS problem than Apple. When the actual OS can be compromised to the point of turning into a zombie and then zombifying other Macs, then I'll worry. While labrats show possibilities that do nothing more than get their name in today's Yahoo article, I am not impressed.
    4) Programs crash - Yes, they do. Programs are fallible. Operating systems are fallible. However, when a program crashes, I've yet to see it take the OS with it. OS X still runs like a champ. OS X can crash, too, though I've only managed to crash it while experimenting with how many OS's I can run simultaneously (Win98, WinXP, Win311, MacOS 6, C64, N64....). I also had some strange settings on those virtual machines, such as using chip features that my chip may not have had. I've since had success keeping them all running without crashes.


    If you want to like MS, that's ok. I'm not advocating you switch to Apple, but please stop with the lies that were hardly true in the 90's, let alone 2007. And Leopard.... will knock Vista even further into the past.


    BTW, to all you Ubuntu advocates.... as soon as I clear some hard drive space, I think that'll be the next virtual machine I create. I think I finally need to have a look. :)

  • I have actually been quite happy with XP, and I see no reason for me get Vista. Yes, there have been a few little problems now and again with XP, but nothing I couldn't handle. I must agree that I haven't heard a single good thing about Vista, which I was expecting.

  • Anonymous

    Put as only a mac user could

  • macuser

    Lots of M$ astroturf around here...

  • Lancelot9201

    After 8 out of 10 customers this last month kept calling me with one problem or another with Vista I decided to refuse to sell any computer with anything other than XP until Vista has a major Service Pack available - What most of you are forgetting is that computers are suppose to be easy to use. Most mon & pop's don't care to be advanced users, they just want what they paid for, a reliable easy to use system that doesn't cost them an arm & a leg. Why no one isn't complaining about M$ charging $400 for Vista Ulitmate & $300 for Office is beyone me.. Also, for my customers who has a kids heading to college I only recommend Apple. Of the 12 or so that have bought one I've not had one complaint. I've not received one call about virus or spyware issues, not one complaint of freezes or hardware compatiblity issues. One did have a fan go bad but had it replaced at an Apple store in one day.
    ~~ Food For Thought~

  • Anonymous

    i dont know whats worse vista or mac users :/

  • @Jonathan Harchick


    Wow! You are a frickin' Idiot! I don't even want to waste my time explaining how every single one of your statements solidifies how stupid you really are.


    Holy crap you are misinformed!

  • So sorry!

    When its time to get a new computer I will be avoiding anything labeled DRM.

  • Bokmade

    Vista It Take to install 10 min


    it debend how fast and new your PC ..

  • Here's my Vista horror story:
    http://www.russbrooks.com/2007...


    -Russ Brooks
    Former Microsoft Devotee of 25 Years

  • Amen brother! I took one look at Vista Beta 2 and bought a MacBook, then a few months later a Mac Pro! I'm happily OS X'ing away now and loving every second of it.


    It's been a year now and I now own an iPhone and am drulling over the upcoming Leopard update.


    Apple/Jobs just "gets" it. Period!

  • I started on PC

    Mac OS X is incredible, rarely does anyone not like it unless they have been hiding from it for years.


    My advice is try all the different systems, but be sure you try the Mac and understand how to use it. Mac is not as easy to use as iPod or iPhone, but it's every bit as impressive if you understand how it works. Windows can't compare.


    What is Microsoft going to do? I think their stock is going to fall before long.

  • Apple Shareholder

    I'll just say how very grateful I am for Windows Vista. It's a major contributing factor to the increase in Apple's share price over the last year.


    Every Apple supporter should urge Microsoft users to take a good, close look at Vista, and then visit an Apple store. That's what will get us 100% year-over-year market share gains.

  • blinx


    Have you REALLY worked on / around Macs before? Have you ever seen the Apple BOMB?



    I haven't seen that in 5 years. What're you on? And I don't run any anti-crapware software - don't need it. Occasionally a poorly-written app might just quit. Relaunching immediately is no problem.



    Macs ask for a password to install programs, and their commercials complain about PCs asking for a password.



    Nope, they ask for a password on occasion, like when an installer wants to place system files, but most apps just drag from a disk image into the Applications folder and don't require a password.


    The real paid trolls here are the ones who say they have installed Vista and have had no problems. Besides, when you get a Mac you have the option of running Microcrapware on it too - the last stage in the cure process for those suffering from Stockholm Syndrome.

  • Some Guy

    Jonathon,


    You forgot to mention the very best thing about Microsoft: they'll hire ANYONE to shill for them, even a semi-literate, utterly transparent liar like yourself!

  • Problems with Macs


    Programs do crash, OSX does crash, and there are viruses for Macs, but some Mac users claim this is not true.


    There is no way to change the color of the text on icons


    When the dock is big, and the desktop icons are on auto arrange the icons hide under the dock, and you can't click on them.


    Macs come with trial software, but they claim they don't


    Macs don't come with a simple drawing program (like MS paint)


    The Grid spacing is to far apart, and there is no way to change it.


    You can't open bookmarks (at the very top of the screen) in a new tab with the center click.


    Apple hardware is overpriced (the cinema display for example).


    They hide information from there customers, wail Microsoft is very public about there projects


    Not as many hardware options (no tablet PCs, and no internal TV tuners, or internal memory card readers)


    You can't see a thumbnails of videos in a folder.


    Macs ask for a password to install programs, and their commercials complain about PCs asking for a password.


    When copying a file, or rendering a video, the estimated remaining time never seems to be accurate until it is half way done.


    The USB extension cable for the keyboard only works with the apple keyboard.

  • chris

    Yeah, I was using xp and tried vista. Both often caused me to pull my hair out. Then I went to osx and macs and my life is sooooo much better. I used to be a big microsoft fan. Apple products including software just seem to work better and I feel like such an idiot for being a microsoft slave all those years.

  • klmd

    maybe in a year ot two Vista will close the back door the government is using to spy with.

  • YAD

    Hello everyone,


    I've been a poweruser for as long as the personal computer existed. I've extensively used every version of DOS and Windows till Vista. I do scientific research on Debian (Linux) and IRIX (Unix), and I need to work on Windows 2000 at work for corporate reasons. At home, I have Powerbook G4 running OS X Tiger, an old laptop running XP, and a desktop that dual boots XP and RedHat Linux. It used to triple-boot (I had Win98 running for a while).


    I've been supporting family members and many friends with their computers. I've supported WinPCs, Macs and Linux boxes. I've helped set-up and establish a number of networks and clusters. I have always tried to understand the user-experience on every platform.


    So, when a few asked for help installing Vista for them, or helping them with new computers (all the bells and whistles) running Vista, I came across every single complaint shared here. I was able to help, but the experience got me to reflect on the "Wow" factor.


    Since I can't claim to be an expert on Vista, I can't really tell someone that it is good or bad. I can only compare installation and maintenance to the other OSs. The initial expectation I had that this would be easier and more straight forward with Vista. It was not. What I'm hearing from the people I help does not indicate they are enjoying their experience with Vista. Most compare it negatively to XP, excepting cosmetics.


    So I'm guessing/hoping this will improve with future SP releases.


    For now, I will not upgrade my Win OSs to Vista. Waiting is safer.


    As for what I think would be good for users, here is the breakdown:


    1- Mac OS X would be an OS that a 4 year old (not kidding here), a geek and a 90 year old would be able to use with complete ease. In its current incarnation, it is extremely stable. I have never had to do a hard reboot, and have rarely had to support someone using a mac. Best choice for noobies in my opinion. Given the switch to Intel, Macs can now run all 3 major OSs: OS X, Linux and Windows (XP and Vista). So for a poweruser or a gamer, it would be a practical choice, and there is virtually nothing that cannot be done on a mac. The hardware is high quality, and resale value is great.


    2- For powerusers that want to build their own boxes, use older hardware or are on a budget; and for putting together computer clusters, Linux is the way to go. Debian on a desktop is arguably the most stable OS out there. Although Linux (especially Ubunto) has come a long way, I would not yet suggest it to a complete noobie to computers, my child or my my grandmother. With Linux, you definitely get a great deal of freedom to play under the hood. Not everything can be done on Linux, yet. But open source software is very rapidly closing the gap. Wine continues to improve, and support for software designed for Windows is progressively growing.


    3- For the rest, people with some experience on computers (enough to keep it firewalled, malware free and defragged) but are not really geeks, as well as hard-core gamers, a well-maintained XP SP2 would also do. I would advise this group to consider Vista in a year or two, rather than right now.

  • John

    Mac Hardware is the same or less expensive as Dells
    I made the switch to Apples about 8-9 months ago. I use to use Linux and
    WinXP(more xp though). I made the switch to a MacBook Pro and never looked
    back. Macs have tons of open source software, commercial software, freeware etc.
    I could never use Windows again after using OS X.


    Contrary to what many believe...for comparable hardware Macs are either about the
    same price as a Dell or less expensive. See the link below to the comparisons.


    http://www.systemshootouts.org...


    So for all the people complaining about Mac Hardware prices.. stop spreading FUD
    and ignorance!

  • I run OSX Tiger on an 11-year-old Powerbook (500mhz Pismo). It installed and runs like butter. I use it everyday. At work, I use multiple PCs (I work at a software co.) with all the Windows OS's. One of my coworkers (a PC engineer) noticed me using OSX during lunch and asked me to try different things ("Let's see it do dock animations!") as if searching for something the old laptop could not do. But it was flawless. Yes, the apps ran slower that they would on a newer machine, but they RAN and did not crash. He couldn't fathom how the hell it worked. I even ran multiple apps to show him how stable it was. He dismissed it, saying Vista was superior. I told him to install Vista on an 11-year-old PC laptop and see how far he gets.

  • Anonymous

    I run OSX Tiger on an 11-year-old Powerbook (500mhz Pismo). It installed and runs like butter. I use it everyday. At work, I use multiple PCs (I work at a software co.) with all the Windows OS's. One of my coworkers (a PC engineer) noticed me using OSX during lunch and asked me to try different things ("Let's see it do dock animations!") as if searching for something the old laptop could not do. But it was flawless. Yes, the apps ran slower that they would on a newer machine, but they RAN and did not crash. He couldn't fathom how the hell it worked. I even ran multiple apps to show him how stable it was. He dismissed it, saying Vista was superior. I told him to install Vista on an 11-year-old PC laptop and see how far he gets.

  • XP good, Vista horrid, OS X go

    Ive used XP for years (since the day it was released) and I love it. It has been stable for me and on a game machine it simply does what its suppose to which is stay out of the way.
    XP is that older lady down the street who is still kinda hot and has a few tricks left up her sleeve. Shes stable, easy to have fun with and likes games.


    Ive tried Vista on another machine......HOLY CRAP....I cant believe they released this mess! Slow, Unstable, Bloated, I call it the Hollywood OS, it might be pretty to look at but its vapid, empty headed and any kind of relationship with it will only last a very short time before you serve it papers.


    OS X is like that hot chick that can carry on a conversation about something other than shopping, better yet she has low expectations so you might actually get to first base with her.

  • Windows vista sucks, there are nothing more than beutiful desktop. I have windows xp and ubuntu on my machine :P

  • J

    When you switch to a mac, you won't miss Microsoft within a week. Goodluck and thanks for a funny article.

  • Ken

    Ubuntu for school > all


    Windows for games and nothing more


    osx...i have Tux :D

  • Rhenthalin

    When will you Ubuntu?

blog comments powered by Disqus